The Distributed Energy Blogs

The Blogger

Elizabeth Cutright

More from this blogger

Distributed Energy Editor's Blog

  • RSS
  • Save
  • Print
  • Email
Tuesday, July 31, 2012 10:22 AM

Can We Avoid the Future?

By: Elizabeth Cutright Comments

There’s not much to say that you haven’t already heard before about our nation’s infrastructure crisis—$2 trillion and counting—and the delicate water/energy nexus. Dire warnings and scary prognostications have not done the trick apparently, as our communities and local governments still find themselves facing budget shortfalls that have morphed from an inconvenient economic cliff hanger to almost insurmountable abyss (http://water.epa.gov/infrastructure/sustain/infrastructureneeds.cfm).

Doom is on the horizon, and for some countries the water/energy crisis has already arrived.

Earlier this week, more than 370 million Indian citizens found themselves without power for several hours in what’s been described as “a massive electrical grid failure.”* And while transit systems were in disarray for most of the day—stranding commuters and causing traffic gridlocks—government officials were primarily concerned with water supply disruptions. 

The blackout forced water pumps to a standstill, and underground reservoirs around New Delhi were immediately affected by the power failure. The effect on water treatment plants is expected to be widespread. The New Delhi Water Board’s water treatment plants do not have backup power systems, according to Sanham Cheema, spokeswoman for the Delhi Jal Board, and because these treatment plants run on a 24 hour clock, Cheema warns that “even slight disruptions can affect them.” 

Although power was restored to most residents and businesses by the end of the day on Tuesday, for many the outage is a harbinger of things to come. The Confederation of Indian Industry seized the opportunity to demand that the Indian government “fix the power sector, ensure a steady supply of coal for power plants, and reform the electricity utilities.” 

The blackout is an extreme consequence of the country’s tricky power resource balance. As the India morphs into an international economic powerhouse, demand continues to increase, while supply struggles to catch up. The grid failure was the worst to hit India in about a decade, but experts warn that brownouts and blackouts could occur with increasing regularity.   

Meanwhile, government officials were quick to point out India is not alone when it comes to grid failures and power shortages. As the Washington Post reports, Power Minister Sushil Kumar Shine “deflected criticism, pointing out that the United States and Brazil also had huge power failures in recent years.”

“I ask you to look at the power situation in other countries as well,” said Shine.

Regardless of the political motivation behind his warning, we’d all be well advised to listen to the substance of Shine’s statement. The truth is that around the world water, energy, economic growth, and dwindling resources are all combining to create a perfect storm. We’d better batten down the hatches, because we could be the next nation in the water/energy nexus crosshairs.


*(Update: News agencies are now reporting that the number of residents effected by the power outages in Indian have topped 600,000,000, nearly half of the nation's population.)

What Do You Think?

 

Ron Harben

Thursday, August 02, 2012

Unless the political and economic climate changes in the US (and it's highly doubtful that they can change!), it will not be possible to improve either the water or power infrastructure: It would cut into corporate profits too much. First of all, Congress would not be able to agree that there actually is a looming crisis at hand - they (especially the Republicans) deny scientific data at our peril. The tobacco industry first started the "doubt the science" scenario then the power industry (Koch brothers) used it to deny climate change. Naomi Oreskes, co-author of "Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming", describes how a small group of retired cold-war nuclear physicists, who through their weapons work had become well-connected, well-known and influential people, promoted the idea of 'doubt' in several areas of US public debate. According to Oreskes, they did this, "not for money, but in defense of an ideology of laissez-faire governance and opposition to government regulation".

Therefore the outlook for anything that reduces profits - such as improving the electricity grid - is doomed from the start. The voters of the US are so politically divided that no concensus could ever be reached until an actual disaster strikes. Even then, the corporations will try to blame anyone and everyone except their own greed and complicity and the House Republicans will try to use the crisis to exact budget concessions from the Democrats. "The point is that the prospect of disaster, no matter how obvious, is no guarantee that nations will do what it takes to avoid that disaster. And this is especially true when pride and predjudice make leaders unwilling to see what should be obvious." Paul Krugman, Europe's great illusion, New York Times, July 3, 2012.

Gar

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

We've got to learn from this!

Post a Comment

Note from the Editor: The content that appears in our "Comments" section is supplied to us by outside, third-party readers, and organizations and does not necessarily reflect the view of our staff or Forester Media—in fact, we may not agree with it—and we do not endorse, warrant, or otherwise take responsibility for any content supplied by third parties that appear on our website. All comments are subject to approval.

CAPTCHA Validation
CAPTCHA
Code:

 

Distributed Energy Email Updates!

Get weekly news and updates through our email newsletter!